Who am I? Sonic edition

[Geoffrey St John 175]

Oh great then you take it Skye.

[MetalSkulkBane_PL 18]

According to rules: -The winner got 48 hours to make a new question, otherwise it's someone else their turn. No one said who gets a turn But I'm assuming that's anyone who wants.

So I'm taking this one: In my first appearance I wanted to rule it all, In my second you've never seen me fall, In appearance number three, till the end you didnt know it was me.

Who am I?

[Geoffrey St John 175]

Hmm tough one but based upon my memories I seem to think Dr Finitevus.

[Princess Blaze 347]

Enerjak?

[MetalSkulkBane_PL 18]

Nope and Nope. I add this to clarity: by fall I meant defeat not literal fall to the ground.

[Julie-Su98 0]

Scourge the Hedgehog?

[Geoffrey St John 175]

Based upon your clues I now think you may mean Ixis Naugus.

[MetalSkulkBane_PL 18]

No. A litle bit more obscure villain, but as you can tell, he/she had at least 3 apearances

[Geoffrey St John 175]

In which case I am thinking Patch/ Anti Antoine.

[MetalSkulkBane_PL 18]

Interesting guess, but no. He wasnt beaten off-screen in his second apearance. I'add that this character worked for Robotnik and first appeared in NOT a main series.

[Geoffrey St John 175]

You don't mean Nack the weasel do you?

[MetalSkulkBane_PL 18]

No I dont.

[Geoffrey St John 175]

Hmm well there is one other possibility is Regina Furrum.

[MetalSkulkBane_PL 18]

Ok what if I sat that this character propably doesnt consider Sonic as main nemesis.

[Geoffrey St John 175]

Doesn't consider Sonic their main nemesis? That changes things and now I am thinkinh Eve.

[MetalSkulkBane_PL 18]

No. If you think about it Sonic barely ever fought that villain. Heck, Knothole Freedom Fighters arent his/hers biggest problem.

[Geoffrey St John 175]

You really not making this any easier but unless you are talking about Lien-da I am clueless.

[Simon Arty 14]

This seems tough, makes me think its Helmut Von Stryker for some reason.

[MetalSkulkBane_PL 18]

Les gather clues: rules wannabe, defeated off-screen in second appearance, plot twist appearance in third, debut outside main-series, Robotnik's minion, fought someone other that Sonic. Also: forth appearance was written by Ian Flynn. I have no idea what else I can say.

[Geoffrey St John 175]

Beaten off screen? Wait do you mean Bean?

[Simon Arty 14]

I have my guess, is it Crocbot?

[MetalSkulkBane_PL 18]

Congratulation, yes its Crocbot. See Geoff, during ENDGAME Crocbot appeared as warden of Downunda prison. Bunnie and Antoine were prisoners there but escaped. Later we learned that he was defeated in Super Sonic Special number 4.

[Simon Arty 14]

Woo hoo! I knew it! :D Well here's mine: I've been known for my extreme and controversial decisions for my people and of the "greater good." Who am I?

[Princess Blaze 347]

Dimitri?

[Geoffrey St John 175]

You are me Geoffrey St John.

And I clicked when I saw the name crocbot.